
So, uh, did you know the story of Sam Cooke? I didn’t. Somehow. It’s awesomely seedy, though — rife with controversy and prurience and sadly hilarious.
We’ll start with what makes Cooke honorable (presuming you think someone who’s really good at one thing publicly but is privately quite the glimmering douchebag can still be honorable). Dude can sing, of course. Never minding that he’s responsible for some of the worst ‘oldies’ currently playing ad infinitum in retro diners coast to coast (Twistin’ the Night Away, were you Sam?), he also put some heavy, kickass business down on tape. The heaviest? Probably “A Change is Gonna Come” in 1963. This is a muscular, anthemic (but surprisingly short) record that rightfully still carries a lot of the momentum of 1960s civil rights work.
“Change” is reported to be a response, at least in part, to an incident in Shreveport, La where Cooke and his entourage were initially booked at a Holiday Inn but refused a room upon arrival. Looking past the fact that they even wanted to stay at a Holiday Inn, which is funny, the open racial bastardry of those Holiday Innsters made Cooke, you know, pissed the fuck off. So he honked his horn and probably yelled and whatever else you do when you’re denied something because of your race (I wouldn’t know, I’m a whitey). And all the white desk clerks and middle managers panicked, of course, and called the cops and Cooke was shuffled off to the hoosegow.
Following this event, among others, Cooke finished off this frank, curt statement about the plight of African Americans in the U.S. up to the mid 1960s. It’s especially interesting because it essentially says “watch the fuck out, folks,” but does so within a lavish, easy-on-the-white-ears ballad production and arrangement.
I guess things have changed for the better. Your average Holiday Inn desk clerk isn’t likely to engage in open racial hostility at least. (Aside: but what is your average Holiday Inn desk clerk likely to engage in, though? That’s a hard species to draw a bead on. They’re almost always well-coifed and clean. Even prim. So you think they’re okay because they behave like business students or party planners. But they’re still, somehow, just defeated. The rest of us wear our losses on our sleeves, kids. Why pretend everything is okay? If I’m booking a room at a Holiday Inn I already know things could be both better and worse, so let’s just tone down the gold hair and the thin beards and behave like human beings, yes?)

But I digress. The last, most painful joke in all of this is the irony that both of Cooke’s wildest, most signature moments — the resistance at Holiday Inn and his death — happened at hotels. You can look up Cooke’s story pretty much anywhere as it’s evidently still warmly contested. Here’s a brief version: Cooke and sketchy lady friend speed away from a party to the Hacienda Hotel in L.A. (the location for this track, by the way); lady friend claims Cooke gets handsy, so she absconds with herself and a decent batch of Cooke’s wad; Cooke storms around grounds of la Hacienda looking for said lady friend, ends up frightening hotel manager, who makes with the pow-pow-pow and sends Cooke to the floor; at which time she thumps him a few more times with some wooden implement, sometimes reported to be a broom handle. Yowza! Of course the best detail is Cooke’s missing shoe and undershirtless sports coat, but let’s show some respect, shall we?
Anyway, it’s “A Change is Gonna Come,” but not Sam Cooke’s version with the strings and all of that bullshit. Strings ruin songs. Strings ruin songs. Most of the time, anyway, and this is one of them. Imagine how awesome this song would be if Cooke recorded it in a room full of percussionists. Just percussionists and Cooke’s voice. Am I right?
Odd, then, that I would choose a version that’s…strings! Or string, more like it — it’s Ben Sollee doing this song with just a cello (yet another from the excellent Daytrotter series). It’s pretty good, really. Nice and sparse and pretty powerful if you can handle hearing this come from a white NPR darling from Lexington.
“A Change is Gonna Come,” by Ben Sollee at his August, 2008 Daytrotter Session.
And the kml for all mp3s of the week.
Oh, also some citations:
“Soul man who signed in for a violent death,” Western Daily Press: October 11: 2005.
“Soul Man,” The New York Times (Late Edition): November 20, 2005.
“Rolling on Rock’s Long Road,” The Herald (Glasgow): May 17, 1997.
Capture from “Sam Cooke Slain in Coast Motel: Singing Star Shot to Death in Los Angeles Incident,” New York Times: 1964, December 12.